When Silence Isn’t Peace: Navigating Emotional Withdrawal in Relationships
by Choi Soolin
Counsellor / Career Coach
When Silence Isn’t Peace: Navigating Emotional Withdrawal in Relationships
In the middle of an argument, one partner shuts down—arms folded, eyes downcast, words cut off. Silence fills the room, but it’s not the peaceful kind. It’s a heavy pause that leaves both partners feeling hurt, rejected, and unheard. This is emotional withdrawal, also known as stonewalling, and while it may feel protective in the moment, it can erode trust and intimacy over time. Here’s what emotional withdrawal looks like, why it happens, and how couples can break the cycle together.
-
Emotional withdrawal happens when one partner shuts down emotionally, avoiding conflict or connection. It can look like silence, stonewalling, or detachment.
-
Stonewalling signals emotional disconnection. It often makes the other partner feel abandoned, escalating conflict and weakening trust.
-
Approach with curiosity, not blame. Ask gentle questions, suggest breaks instead of walls, and create a safe space for emotions.
-
Yes. Counselors or Psychotherapists use evidence-based methods like the Gottman Method to help couples break the withdrawal cycle and rebuild connection.
In the middle of a heated discussion, one partner suddenly goes quiet. They turn away, arms folded, eyes downcast. The silence stretches. The other partner, now unsure how to respond, either escalates or walks away—also hurt, also unheard.
This is a moment many couples recognize: not a quiet lull of mutual comfort, but a heavy silence filled with tension. While silence can be golden, in intimate relationships, it can also be a form of emotional withdrawal—a quiet signal that something deeper is wrong.
What Emotional Withdrawal Looks Like
Emotional withdrawal can take many forms. It might be:
Stonewalling in arguments (refusing to engage or respond),
Pulling back from conversations,
Avoiding physical affection or eye contact,
Becoming overly absorbed in work, hobbies, or digital devices,
Saying “I’m fine” when clearly not.
At its core, emotional withdrawal is a form of self-protection. It often emerges when someone feels overwhelmed, shut down, or uncertain how to express difficult feelings. But while it might be intended as a pause or buffer, withdrawal can feel like rejection to the other person—and over time, it chips away at the emotional fabric of the relationship.
Stonewalling: A Closer Look
In the Gottman Method, a research-based approach to couples therapy, stonewalling is identified as one of the “Four Horsemen” of relationship breakdown (alongside criticism, defensiveness, and contempt). It’s the act of shutting down or tuning out during conflict—like a wall going up between partners.
Often, stonewalling is a physiological response. The person withdrawing may be experiencing “flooding”—a state of emotional overwhelm that makes it hard to process or respond calmly. Their heart rate increases, their body goes into fight-or-flight mode, and silence becomes a coping strategy.
But to the partner on the receiving end, stonewalling can feel like abandonment. They might interpret the silence as indifference, punishment, or a lack of care. This dynamic—one partner pursuing, the other withdrawing—can become a painful cycle that both reinforces disconnection and prevents resolution.
Why Silence Isn’t Always Safe
There’s a difference between a mutually agreed-upon pause to cool down and the kind of silence that isolates. Silence can feel deceptively peaceful—less conflict, fewer raised voices—but underneath, resentment may simmer.
Over time, emotional withdrawal creates distance. Partners stop sharing what they think, feel, or need. Vulnerability dries up. Even joyful or neutral moments—like sharing a funny story or checking in after work—become rare. Eventually, one or both partners may feel like roommates, not romantic partners.
In some relationships, especially those shaped by earlier experiences of emotional neglect or trauma, withdrawal becomes a learned survival strategy. If, for example, someone grew up in a home where emotions were unsafe or ignored, they may not know how to stay emotionally present when things get hard. They may not even be aware they’re withdrawing—only that it feels safer than saying something wrong or being misunderstood.
How to Reconnect When Withdrawal Becomes the Norm
The good news is that emotional withdrawal is not the end of the story. With awareness and intentional effort, couples can rebuild safety, connection, and emotional engagement.
1. Recognize the Pattern (Without Blame)
Start by noticing when and how withdrawal shows up. Is it during conflict? After a long day? When one partner expresses a need?
The goal here isn’t to label one partner as “the problem,” but to understand how the pattern functions. Often, both people contribute to the cycle—one by withdrawing, the other by escalating or pursuing.
2. Understand What’s Underneath the Silence
Withdrawal often hides softer emotions: fear, shame, helplessness, sadness. It’s easier to say nothing than to admit, “I feel like I’m failing you,” or “I don’t know how to make this better.”
Creating space for those vulnerable feelings can help bring down the walls. This might sound like:
“I shut down because I didn’t know how to say what I was feeling.”
“I felt overwhelmed and needed time, but I should’ve told you that instead of disappearing.”
In counselling or couple’s therapy, many couples are surprised to learn that the partner who goes quiet isn’t being cold—they’re trying not to make things worse.
3. Use Breaks, Not Walls
If you notice you’re about to shut down, it’s okay to take a break—but make it a communicated break. For example: “I’m feeling really overwhelmed and need 20 minutes to calm down. Can we pause and come back to this after dinner?”
This approach signals care rather than disconnection. It also prevents the other person from feeling abandoned or dismissed.
4. Learn Emotional Regulation Together
Withdrawal is often a sign that one or both partners struggle with regulating big emotions. Learning emotional regulation tools—such as breathing techniques, grounding, or naming your feelings—can help you stay present even when things feel tough.
In couples counseling, this might be practiced through role plays, mindfulness exercises, or structured dialogues that slow down the pace of conflict.
5. Rebuild Emotional Safety
A key part of resolving withdrawal is creating a space where both partners feel safe enough to express themselves without fear of judgment or escalation. This might mean:
Agreeing on ground rules during conflict (no yelling, no interrupting),
Making regular time for check-ins when you’re both calm,
Practicing small, consistent acts of emotional connection—like asking “How are you really feeling today?”
When to Seek Support
Sometimes, withdrawal becomes so entrenched that couples can’t break the cycle on their own. A skilled couples therapist or counsellor can help untangle the dynamics, surface hidden emotions, and guide partners toward healthier patterns of interaction.
Counselling or therapy isn’t just for relationships in crisis—it’s a space to grow insight, improve communication, and re-learn how to stay present with each other, even during hard moments.
Final Thoughts: The Opposite of Withdrawal Is Presence
Relationships thrive not on perfect communication, but on emotional engagement. When partners stay curious about each other’s inner worlds—even when those worlds feel messy or unfamiliar—they build resilience, trust, and intimacy.
So if you’ve noticed more silence than connection in your relationship lately, don’t assume peace has arrived. Ask yourself: What’s beneath the silence—and what might happen if we found the courage to speak?
If silence has started to replace connection in your relationship, you don’t have to face it alone. At The Counselling Place in Singapore, our couples therapists use evidence-based approaches to help partners break free from withdrawal patterns, communicate safely, and rebuild intimacy.
Learn more about our Couples Counselling Services. Book a session with me.